Why Organized Religion?

I often hear the argument that organized religion is corrupt, discriminatory, and unnecessary. Some of the arguments supporting this negative view of organized religion are somewhat compelling, especially when looked at in a historical context. In a recent post, Barbara described some of the benefits of organized religion. In this post (and a few in the future), I’d like to explore some of the downsides of organized religion, how the Mormon church has attempted to eliminate them, and why those downsides don’t outweigh the benefits.

First, I want to cite a passage from the Bible that seems to indicate that the original Christian church had a distinct structure:

11 And he gave some, apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and teachers;
12 For the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ:
13 Till we all come in the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man, unto the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ:
14 That we henceforth be no more children, tossed to and fro, and carried about with every wind of doctrine, by the sleight of men, and cunning craftiness, whereby they lie in wait to deceive; (Ephesians 4:11-14)

Here, Paul is speaking of Christ’s organization of his church to the Ephesians. It is clear that the structure of the church consisted of different roles assigned to different people. It is also clear that the main purpose of this structure was unity in purpose and in doctrine.

Now, while this passage seems to clearly indicate the existence of a structured church in the time of the apostles, maybe it’s the case that structure is no longer needed. Maybe the proliferation of the Bible and the spread of literacy have combined to make the need for organized religion obsolete. After all, nearly every individual can now read the words of Christ for him or herself and determine how best to apply His teachings to life, so who needs some minister or priest to tell them whether they’re on track for salvation or whether they are forgiven of their sins or what God wants them to do with their lives? This question is especially pertinent if you believe (as Mormons do) that God answers individuals’ prayers and directs individuals’ lives through a process we call personal revelation.

So is organized religion beneficial or unnecessary? As I’ve thought about this question, I’ve come up with the following costs and benefits:

Benefits:

1. Coordination

-Allows for coordination in serving members of the church and the community

-Allows for coordination in doctrine

2. Peer Effects

-Older, more experienced members of a church can have good influence on children and youth

-New adherents can benefit from the advice of life-long members through organized channels

Costs:

1. Potential for Corruption

-Organized religion inevitably involves positions of power which can be used corruptly to benefit the leader at the cost of the congregation

-Doctrine can become corrupted due to the actions of one or a small group of individuals

2. Operating Costs

-A structured organization requires offices, meetinghouses, etc., which all have monetary costs that could be used elsewhere

In my next few posts, I intend to examine these costs and benefits more closely. I will also discuss how they apply to the Mormon church. But, before I do that, I want to ask for your input. In your mind, what are some of the costs and benefits of organized religion? How do these costs and benefits weigh against each other? I’d really love to hear your responses so I can work them into my future posts.

Pin on Pinterest0Share on Facebook1Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Tumblr0

4 thoughts on “Why Organized Religion?

  1. Teppo says:

    I agree with Brooke and Ravi that organized religion requires more time and money. I think this is both a cost and a benefit because by requiring sacrifice God teaches us to value spiritual goals higher than our time and money.

    I would say the same about Valerie’s comment. It can be really taxing to learn to get along with lots of different people, especially if you strongly disagree with them and yet they may serve as your spiritual leader. But I think God wants us to learn patience, tolerance and Christ-like love. So both a cost and a benefit. I would argue that most benefits require a cost.

  2. Valerie says:

    Hey Tim, I’ve never commented before, but I always really like reading your posts. I like the way you think and you really present your ideas clearly.

    Here are my thoughts on the topic at hand. I think there are some major benefits that come from attending church with people you wouldn’t normally associate with. You mention old vs. young and new vs. seasoned, but there is also the dynamic of spending time with people with different socioeconomic states, educational levels, etc. Especially the fact that you are spending time with them in a setting where you are serving each other and trying to learn to be more loving and charitable. I think everyone benefits whenever people step outside of their normal social group and learn to work together.

  3. Ravi Singh says:

    All people believe in religion. I agree with Brooke Time & Money is the reason behind.

  4. Brooke says:

    I would say sacrifice is a cost of organized religion. Sacrifice especially of people’s time and money. There are a lot of people that are afraid of committing to a religion because of those two reasons. They prefer to believe in the bible without attending a church.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.